Topper Copies

The Supreme Court, in a recent verdict, prescribed a time period for the Governor's assent to state legislative bills. What are the implications of this judgment for cooperative federalism and legislative accountability in India? (Answer in 150 words)

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

Cooperative federalism reconciles shared rule with aspirations for autonomy. The T.N. Governor case of Supreme Court have implications on federalism as well as Parliamentary democracy.

Implications of this Judgement

(A) Cooperative Federalism

1. Reasonable discretion of Governor - balanced relation with State legislative assembly (Nabam Rabia, 2016 Judgement) 2. No indefinite Governor veto on the 'legislative will' of the state legislative. 3. Governor - not as employee of centre but Constitutional head of the state (Harivallabh Pant Judgement) 4. Enhanced federalism - S.R. Bommai - strong states autonomy.

(B) Legislative accountability

1. Equal & Check on Parliamentary decline in the states (legislative vaccuum) 2. Empowered legislation on State list subject (Article 246) e.g. Tamil Nadu laws. 3. Good Governance - continuity of legal reforms e.g. Punjab land digitalization 4. Citizen-empowerment: Accountable laws to people (e.g. West Bengal women safety.

SC used Article 142 to deliver complete justice to empower the states against unreasonable discretion of Governor.