Topper Copies

Arun, renowned for his integrity and dedication, has recently assumed the role of Superintendent at a state Pollution Control Board. This posting, his fourth in just one year, includes the responsibility of overseeing Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs). In his new position, Arun becomes aware of a copper smelting plant situated near a crucial wetland that serves as the primary water source for the region. Despite the plant's notorious reputation for heavy pollution, the current EIA, presented to Arun by the Chairperson, indicates no significant impact on the wetland. The next assessment is not scheduled for another two years. One day, Arun receives a letter from a politician affiliated with the opposition party. The letter contains evidence suggesting that the current EIA results are based on falsified lab reports, allegedly approved by the Chairperson. The Chairperson is known to have close ties with the ruling party, which has been receiving substantial donations from the plant's operators. The opposition politician urges Arun to expose the Chairperson from within the department, arguing that this approach could effectively pressurize the government to conduct a new EIA. He promises Arun significant rewards and support once their party comes to power, an outcome suggested by recent opinion polls. While the evidence presented is compelling, Arun remains cautious about the possibility of being exploited as a political pawn. He is acutely aware of the potential consequences of his actions, both for his career and for the environment. (a) In light of the above case, discuss the ethical issues that may arise from the nexus between corporate, political, and bureaucratic interests. (b) As a conscientious civil servant, evaluate the options available to Arun. Which option should he choose and why?

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

Unethical Nexus between Corporate, Political & bureaucratic interests.

The above case shows how dirty nexus of Politics & Companies give causaulity to Rule of Law at the cost of sustainable development

a) Ethical Issues

1. lack of Accountability of Chairperson to give recognition to plant's notorious heavy pollution 2. Erosion of Objectivity in lab reports where false data is given. 3. Violation of Rule of Law which is transparent EIA. 4. Political rivalries harming neutrality of Civil servants against Code of Conduct Rules, 1964

Options available to Arun

1. Act on evidence given by Opposition Merits - exposure of corrupt practices - harmful for his career good for environment.

Demerits - political pawn & against neutrality. - harmful for his career

2. Take advice of upwright seniors and gather unbiased evidence Merits - like minded approach. - evidence based conduct

Demerits - delays - career harms.

3. Remain silent Merits - smooth career - no impact on personal goals. - Neutrality.

Demerits - environmental damage - may face difficulties if opposition came up

He should choose option (2) Consensus based objective route.

because:- - It is ethical responsibility of Arun to remain neutral & non-partisan. - There should be Deontological reasoning to protect environment, wetlands for environmental ethics. - As a superintendent of State Pollution Control Board, he must ensure Objective implementation of EIA. - There must also be action against lab which presented false reports.

For Arun like Civil servants, it is important to loose oneself, to find himself.