You have been appointed as the Under Secretary in the State Urban Development Department. The Department has been tasked with a prestigious project aimed at revitalizing the infrastructure of a city with deep historical significance. This project, which you are extremely passionate about, involves modernizing public transportation, restoring heritage buildings, and creating green spaces while preserving the city's cultural essence. Excited by the opportunity, you spent weeks researching and drafting a comprehensive proposal. Your plan included innovative ideas for sustainable development, community engagement, and leveraging technology for urban planning. You presented these initial plans in a departmental meeting, hoping to inspire your colleagues and kickstart the project. However, your enthusiasm was met with indifference. Your colleagues showed little interest, failing to contribute ideas or efforts towards the project. Concerned, you reported this lack of enthusiasm to your immediate superior, who is also the authority for this project. To your dismay, he seemed equally indifferent, casually mentioning that he is set to retire in six months and that the project has a long gestation period. Determined to see the project succeed, you took it upon yourself to drive it forward. For the past two months, you have been working more than 12 hours a day, often late into the night, sacrificing time with your family. Your dedication is driven by your belief in the project's potential to transform the lives of the city's residents and preserve its rich heritage for future generations. Two months into the project, a review meeting is called by the Chief Secretary. During the meeting, Department heads from various sectors are present to discuss ongoing and upcoming projects. When it is time to present the urban revitalization project, your boss stands up. To your shock, he presents your draft proposal as his own work, taking all the credit for the innovative ideas and comprehensive planning. As you sit there, listening to your superior claim your hard work as his own, you feel a mix of anger, disappointment, and demoralization. This incident not only undermines your efforts but also leaves you questioning the value of your dedication in a work culture that does not seem to support collaboration or recognize individual contributions. (a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in this case. (b) How does the above-mentioned work culture affect workplace morale and productivity? (c) What are the options available to you and how would you address the situation?
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
Unethical work culture:- where fruits are taken from hardworker to bosses
The above case presents demoralizing scenario where juniors are overburdened, their hardworks are not rewarded, where senior works less & gains more. Such toxic work culture is dangerous in long term.
a) Ethical Issues.
(i) Overburden of work on single member without support system. (ii) Credits taken by senior sidelining true hardworker (iii) Disinuntive for innovation, enthusiasm and dedicated works. (iv) lack of Communication & trust between heirarchies in office (v) Collaborative rewards v/s Competitive (win-win) (one over others)
b) Affect of toxic work culture on workplace morale & productivity
1. less enthusiasms for new work as there is no recognition of hard work. 2. loge of innovative ideas will lead to stagnation of organization. 3. Harm in public relations such as public welfare in such heritage programs. 4. Meritocracy replaced by seniority.
c) Options available to me.
1. Accept the betrayal & carry on work Merits - smooth relations with senior - opacity in public services is selflessness.
Demerits - against my morale & will power to work more hard.
2. Address my senior & ask him to recognize my hardwork Merits - My seniors accountability
Demerits - may be of no help.
3. Approach Chief Secretary for protection of my creativity rights Merits - My IPR Human Right. - precedent to others
Demerits - may not be recognized. - there is no IPR for civil services.
My address to the situation.
I will definitely choose option (2) & ask his accountability with due respect