Topper Copies

'Emergency' is one of the most controversial and widely debated events in Indian politics. How far do you agree with the view that it was imposed to fulfil individual political goals rather than serve national interests? Also, discuss the short-term and long-term impacts of the Emergency.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

Emergency clause in Constitution (A.352) can be implemented on the grounds of internal armed rebellion (earlier disturbances) and external agression.

First imposed in 1975 on 25 June, it was most controversial because -

i. Led to curb of freedoms such as A.19 ii. No clarity over why the need iii. Prosecution of leaders like JP Narayan iv. Passed without cabinet consultation

It was imposed to fulfil political goals ->

i. Indira gandhi v/s Raj Narain judgment of Allahabad HC -> election invalid -> could led to PM resignation ii. Rising protest (eg) Total revolution movement under J.P. iii. Get hold over unchecked power (eg) Suspending fundamental rights iv. Control judiciary (eg) Passing of 42nd AA v. Curb dissent against inflation, poverty vi. Ensure opposition is totally broken by imposing restrictions on parties

But some national interests also

a. Army, police, railway was called for strikes b. Foreign interference after 1971 c. Curb excess disturbances in country

Short term impacts

1. Huge no. of arrests without proper warrants -> leaders put behind jail 2. Unpopular policies passed (eg) Nasbandi Campaign 3. Freedom of speech & expression curbed -> no right to move court under (A.32) 4. Habeus Corpus suspended -> A.K. Gopalan case.

Long term

1. Mass resistance against Indira gandhi's attempt to subvert constitution 2. Non congress govt at centre -> Janta Dall in 1978 3. Amendment -> 44th to prevent it in future 4. Awareness about civil rights 5. Black spot on Indian Democracy -> seminal of importance of civil society. 6. Never imposed again