Differentiate between probity and integrity with suitable examples. How do these values contribute to ethical governance and decision-making in the civil services?
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
Probity is the utmost uprightness in difficult situations. Integrity promotes coherence in belief, action & behaviour.
| Probity | Integrity | |---|---| | Honesty, Upwrightness → Accountability | Action, Belief, Value → Integrity | | Probity help in managing adverse situations.<br>e.g. IAS Mahesh Zagade showed probity by not divesting public funds even under pressure | Integrity helps in fighting cognitive dissonance.<br>e.g. Sam Manekshaw reply to PM Indira Gandhi "We are not ready for war" | | Probity is solution oriented refined by values | Integrity is value oriented refined by Action |
Contribution of Probity.
- Upwrightness towards Code of conduct of civil servants. - Promoting Non-partisanship - Neutrality towards politics, Fairness towards all citizens. - e.g. Inspector Prashant Shankar arrested his own son in liquour smuggling.
Contribution of Integrity.
- Morally, to voice & stand against evil practices. - e.g. Whistleblowing by Dubey Sir. - Financially, not to divest or misappropriate public funds.
In this way, Probity & Integrity are two core pillars of edifice of ethical governance.