A comparison of tribal and mainstream society in India, and the issues that reduce tribal progress.
Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024
India has been a land of diversity where tribal and mainstream societies have coexisted. It was due to freedom provided under the Tribal Panchsheel policy.
Comparative analysis
| Basis | Mainstream society | Tribal society | |---|---|---| | Status | Homogenous nature with common elements. | Heterogenous and diverse. | | Power authority | Social sanctions & role of State | More role of local indigenous leaders. | | Education | Common education based on 5+3+3+4 model of NEP. | Focus on Traditional learning - stories passed from generation | | Gender status | Poor sex ratio & oppression. | High sex ratio & almost equal status to women | | Nature | Away from traditional nature relationship | Worship nature "Sacred groves" "Niyamgiri tribe" |
Yes, tribal society more progressive 1. More gender equal: matriarchal norms in Garo/Khasi tribes 2. Egalitarian society rather than inequality in mainstream 3. Preserve and live with nature: (eg): Revival of Birds in Nagaland by tribes 4. Indigenous knowledge: (eg): Sentinelese Tribe of Andaman survived Tsunami of 2004. 5. No divides of caste, religion threaten the society. 6. Preservation of culture: language preserved since ages -> (eg): Ho & Munda tribal language.
Yet, they face issues reducing their progress 1. Health issues: account for half of malaria deaths. 2. Orthodox practices: sacrifice of animals, using hot rods to cure disease (seen in Odisha) 3. Fear of homogenisation due to globalisation 4. Away from modern technology & education
Both can learn from each other and become progressive. More exchange programs are needed under PM-Janman, Jan Jatiya Gaurav Divas and TRIFED Missions.