Topper Copies

The end cannot justify the means, for the simple and obvious reason that the means employed determine the nature of the ends produced. Discuss with suitable examples.

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

"Beej Boye Babul Ke, Aam Kaise Hoye" (what you sow, you reap!).

Ends cannot justify the means.

1. Deontologically, means should be pure to produce virtuous end. - e.g. Overvaluation of Byjus (means) led to its failure as an end. 2. Karma theory argues only means are in your hands. - e.g. India cultivated soft power through well intentional means - Vaccine Maitree. 3. Gandhiji argues violence cannot bring lasting peace. - e.g. Russia - Ukraine war.

However, Machiavellian principles argue that

Means can justify ends.

1. End of humanitarianism - e.g. Bangladesh liberation war of 1971 (Just war). 2. Scarcity of resources. - e.g. priority to women, children in rescue operations (violating principle of equality). 3. Cultivating social capital. - e.g. threat of civil wars, communal violence dealt with Force.

In this way, Means do determine nature of the ends. But Ends sometimes overpowers means when moral reasoning is done.