How has asymmetric federalism helped India accommodate its diverse regional needs? Discuss with suitable examples.
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
Asymmetric federalism refers to different provisions, powers and special treatment given to different federal units.
Federalism in India - Article 245-263 -> govern centre-state relation - 7th schedule -> ensure list division - NITI Aayog, ISC (263) ensure cooperative federalism
Asymmetry for accomodation 1. Special provisions for tribal areas to accomodate diversities of their culture, practices -> 6th & 5th schedule, PESA etc 2. Administrative asymmetry eg Delhi governed under A.239AA 3. Differential representation in Council of state (Rajya Sabha) under Schedule 4th eg UP v/s Goa 4. Financial asymmetry - Special grants to revenue hit states eg Bihar - Special category status by FC to himalayan states - Central sponsored schemes -> North east get 90:10 share 5. Constitutional differences such as special provisions for states eg Nagaland Gujarat etc 6. Regional needs accomodated by various mechanism eg forming UTs, ISC (263) etc
Asymmetry balance diversity and preserve federal balance with unity.