Electoral bond was brought in as a reform that was high on intent but has proved to be low on substance. Do you agree? Justify.
Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024
Electoral Bonds are bearer instruments issued for political funding by banks. They were brought to reform opaque political funding, yet have had only limited impact on ground.
Reform High on intent 1. Digital trail of donations can be maintained for the donations. 2. Prevent victimization of the donor by other political parties. 3. Reduce role of cash based donations in funding. 4. Reducing role of dummy firm through KYC (Know Your Customer) based donations. 5. Limited dates for donations = 10-15 days every quarter and before elections. 6. Reduce muscle power and criminalisation of politics through Transparency by election body (ECI).
Yet proved low on substance 1. Data sharing issues:- between the State Bank of India and ECI. 2. Harmed the 'right to know' of citizens to check crony capitalism. 3. Limits on corporate donations removed completely 4. Relaxed reporting norms: for the political parties to report donations 5. Majority donations cornered by ruling party. 6. Denial of Electoral Bonds to party with less than 1% vote shares.
Making Electoral Bonds better - Regular reporting of donations to ECI by SBI as directed by Supreme Court - Check funding from dummy and shell companies. - Expressed penalties for non-reporting of donations by parties.
Electoral Bonds can usher a clean and transparent funding of elections with few legislative or judicial interventions.