The critical reason for poor public health indicators in India goes beyond recognition of right to health as fundamental right. Do you think that a statutory framework alone can ameliorate the situation?
Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024
The 15th Finance Commission recommended to incorporate right to health as a fundamental right under Part III of constitution, which has triggered a debate.
Current State of poor health indicators - Children: Stunting 35%. Wasting 19%. (NFHS-5) - Women: Anaemia, period poverty, MMR at 113 (above 70 target). - Other: High out of pocket expenditure (60-70%.)
Benefits of statutory recognition to right to health 1. Accountability of state would increase: who currently spends only 1.2% (state and centre) despite target of 3%. 2. Judicial remedy for those citizens who could not avail the welfare. 3. Force state to invest in health infrastructure in balanced manner (eg: Rural & Urban bias bridged) 4. Greater awareness about right of health can usher socio-economic justice. 5. Legal premise for "Universal Health Coverage" (SDG 3) 6. Prevent poverty due to high expenditure & become a tool to realise demographic dividend through focused and targeted approach. 7. Achievement of DPSP directive under Article 47 = step to promote well being.
However alone will be ineffective: - clog the already burdened judiciary - lack of will and resources cause a hurdle rather than law. - Deviation of focus of executive from welfare to legality.
Rather measures also needed 1. Promotion of preventive health: through lifestyle changes like YOGA, Balanced diet. 2. Governance reforms: to tackle leakages of funds (eg: lakhs of PM-JAY with a fake number as per CAG Report). 3. Reforming the primary health cone: to tackle issues at early stage (Cuban Polyclinic). 4. Boosting R&D in medical field. We need to overall understand Gandhian idea that "Health is the Real wealth" to fulfill SDG3.