Frequent reliance on the ordinance making power by the government, not only dilutes the basic tenets of executive accountability in a parliamentary democracy, but also overlooks the democratic traditions of building consensus. Discuss with relevant examples.
Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024
Promulgation of Ordinance is the power of executive to bring a law through order of President/Governor when atleast one of the house is not in session.
Their frequency of usage has increased both in Parliament and State legislature:- 1. Overturning judicial tenor by bringing an ordinance for Delhi Public Service Authority to manage transfer of officers. 2. Reforms for Space sector were also brought by an ordinance 3. Several states like MP & UP diluted the labour laws through use of ordinance which harmed rights of labour.
All these leads to negative outcomes 1. Dilutes accountability of executive: as the ordinance remains undiscussed till the session is called which has itself reduced.
[a bar chart of Parliamentary sitting days per year: 120 days in 1950, 70 days in 2020]
2. Democratic traditions overlooked: 1. No thorough debate on the effect of the bill. 2. Lost opportunity to direct bill to standing committee of houses. 3. Against the idea of constitutionalism when repeatedly promulgated. 4. Bypassing scrutiny of legislative and leading to violation of rights of those affected.
Supreme Court Role Held in DC Wadhwa Case, RC Cooper case that ordinance making power: - is subject to judicial review - ought not be re-promulgated again and again (as seen in Bihar).
The idea must be to use ordinances only in "URGENCY" and disclose the same in Preamble of the Bill for a healthy parliamentary practice.