Topper Copies

Considering the non-enforceable nature of fundamental duties and directive principles of state policy, critically examine their impact in socio-political norms.

Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024

The Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP) and Fundamental duties are covered under Part IV (Article 36-51) and Part IV A (Article 51A) of the Indian Constitution.

Unlike fundamental rights that are non-enforceable, thus making their impact a mixed bag.

Impact in socio-political norms

A) Directive Principle of state policies Visible positive impact: 1. Article 40: Calls for grassroot democracy brought via 73rd/74th Amendment Act. 2. Article 50: Separation of powers through check & balances by three organs. 3. Worker benefits: Worker participation in management via Labour codes, minimum wage under Code of Wages. 4. Inclusive Growth: by reforms such as progressive taxation, land reforms to check concentration of wealth. 5. Others: steps for health, environment also taken.

Scope for Improvement: - Inequality on rise (Oxfam Report) - Grassroot democracy becoming dependent and "agents" of government - Work towards living wage, universal health coverage.

B) Fundamental Duties Visible impact positive: 1. Respect for flag, anthem, constitution via National Honours Act. 2. Spirit of enquiry under 51A(h) ushered through education 3. Right to education (Article 21A) promoted duty led to near 100% enrolment due to duty under 51A(k).

Scope for improvement: - Overcome colonial mindset and remember ideals of freedom struggle. - New duties: cleanliness, pay taxes. - Reduce issues of women (social, political, economic) to bring women led empowerment & dignity.

DPSP and FD have to widely promoted to create an awareness among citizens. Only then India could march faster towards its goal of becoming a "developed Nation by 2047".