Topper Copies

Basic structure doctrine has prevented the Parliament, a creature of the constitution, from becoming the master of the constitution. Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws.

Madhav Agarwal, AIR 16, 2024

Basic structure doctrine (BSD) has been successful in protecting fundamental essence of constitution while ensuring brute majority in legislature does not turn into tyranny of the same.

Relevant Case laws

A) Evolution: under the Keshavananda Bharti case 1973 and backed by series of 24th/25th Amendment as well as case laws such as Golaknath case: No power to amend Constitution with parliament, while the opposite Shankari Prasad case which said Parliament can amend anything.

Ideas of judicial review, federalism, developed into BSD.

B) Application: 1. Protection of judicial review and marking it as omnipresent in Minerva Mills case 2. SR Bommai case: laid down norms for working of Article 356 (Presidents rule) and ensures federalism as part of BSD. 3. NJAC Judgement 2016: which turned down the 99th Constitutional Amendment on the precedence of harming judicial independence.

BSD, even though criticized for judicial supremacy and expanding definition, has been a "NORTH STAR" (CJI DY Khandsachud) ensuring constitutional supremacy.