Examine the scope and significance of the Supreme Court's advisory jurisdiction under Article 143 of the Constitution.
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
Article 143 provides for the advisory jurisdiction, wherein the President can seek advise of SC on certain matters.
Scope 1. Two cases - a) Pre constitutional treaties, convention etc -> SC is binded to give its opinion - b) Presidential references on constitutional interpretation -> can choose not to give 2. Advise tendered is not binding on Prez. 3. In recent Tamil Nadu Case -> SC asked Prez to consult in A143 if state bill is reserved for constitutional grounds
Significance 1. Better explanation of Constitutional provisions eg Minorities meaning in A29. 2. Clarity > Ambiguity -> SC can clear what "substance" lies in words 3. Unlock mind of constitutional makers -> what they intended 4. Creative reinterpretation for expanding scope eg A21 in various cases 5. Prez. can get expert advise to fulfill his/her duty meaningfully as guardian of constitution 6. Upholding constitution as a living document -> needing clarity with changing times.
Advisory powers are unique to Indian judiciary, making it most powerful.