You are a well-known social worker who has worked for many social causes like girls' education, campaigns against female foeticide and infanticide, child labour etc. You enjoy popularity and credibility among the local population for the work that you have done. Recently, a couple, who is also your distant relative, meet you to seek your counsel on an issue. They convey that a few months ago, they hired a women to act as a surrogate mother and that now she is pregnant with twins. But as per them, they wanted only one child. So they asked the concerned lady to abort one of the fetuses but she is refusing to do so. Upon meeting the lady, you come to know that she already has two children and her financial condition won't allow her to look after one more child. In fact, her decision to act as a surrogate mother was influenced by the financial incentives she would receive. She can't even take legal recourse as commercial surrogacy has been banned in the country. Both the parties look up to you to find an amicable solution. Given the situation, (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the case? (b) What are the various options that you have? Which one of these will you adopt? Justify your stand with logical arguments.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
(a) ethical issues involved - - responsibility of taking care of child that will be born. - livelihood means < right or wrong. - Breach of law - liability of couple to do illegal act. - liability of the women - who did out of necessity. (closely resembles case of begging (to be legal or not to be)).
(b) Various options available - a) Ask the lady to abort one of the fetuses. - risk to lady's life. - couple satisfied, will have only one child. b) Ask lady to not abort fetuses. - who will take care of "unwanted" child. Couple is not ready. Lady is not in the capacity to do so. c) Inform legal authorities about illegal act. - lady & couple both will suffer legal consequences. - lady's children will be in far worse off state. - who will take care of twins in lady's womb.
My course of action - 1. I'll ask the couple to take care of both the children. It's not lady's fault that there are twins. 2. There might be health risks if lady's ask to abort the fetuses. 3. I'll then work on a campaign to make commercial surrogacy legal. Reasons - a) There are many women practising commercial surrogacy but due to lack of enforceable contracts, they suffer injustice. b) There should be legal guidelines of what age, how healthy and other medical requirements for a women to be surrogate. c) Women have the right to their body and surrogacy is no harm, until and unless it is done under doctor's supervision. d) It caters to the needs of the couples as well, who go abroad or do it illegally to have a child.
Thus, this will be my stand as a social reformer to ensure better rights to women who suffer due to lack of legal help.