The Ken-Betwa link project is expected to provide annual irrigation of 10.62 lakh hectares, drinking water supply to about 62 lakh people and also generate 103 MW of hydropower. At the same time, the ambitious project will lead to a large-scale displacement of the people. A total area of about 9,000 hectares will be submerged due to the proposed dam. Some of the area also lies within the Panna Tiger Reserve, considered to be the core habitat of tigers in the region. People fear losing their livelihoods as well. Due to these issues, there has been an ongoing protest by the local people against the project. You, as the head of the project, are given the responsibility to ensure timely completion of the project and ensure its success, as it spearheads India's ambition of river interlinking. Consider the following questions: (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) Discuss the steps that can be taken to address these issues. Also suggest some long term measures for such issues.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
a) Ethical issues involved - - Livelihood of the local people - Conservation of forests. - Displacement of people - Long term effects of dam construction - silting - flood - hindrance for tigers mobility - loss of biodiversity. - Irrigation for farmers - Better Agriculture - reduce farmer suicides. - Water to areas far from rivers - Effective management of water in two rivers - otherwise unconnected.
(b) Steps that can be taken to address these issues
a) Most of the people at the risk of displacement - are forest/illiterate people. It need to be made sure that whatever welfare scheme (displacement compensation or alternate homes) should reach them. Ensure ground analysis with regular field visits. b) talk to the villagers directly, hear their grievances & direct enforcing agencies to ensure transparent redressal. c) Alternate livelihoods should be created. Government welfare schemes like MGNREGA, registration on e-Shram portal should reach them. d) For initial period, they should also be provided food from PDS system and other basic amenities should be met. e) It should be made sure that core areas of tigers are not affected. They should have drinking water within their vicinity. and not
Some long term measures to address these issues - a) NGT approval should be necessary for these projects so that they do not affect biodiversity of the region. b) Special committee should be created that looks into the issues of displaced population due to projects like Ken-Betwa or Narmada Bachao Aandol incidents. c) Displaced people should be adequately compensated. Most tribal people could not produce land records. These people's needs should also be compensated. d) Certain monthly allowances for displaced should be provided initially and later they could be provided with adequate livelihood according to their skills. e) Children of the displaced people should be given proper education.