You are posted as a District Magistrate in a communally sensitive district of the country. Due to the recent upsurge in the COVID-19 cases, a strict lockdown has been imposed in the district. However, a religious festival is upcoming and a particular community wants to organize a big fair to celebrate the festival despite the lockdown guidelines. People from the other community were also allowed to celebrate their festival a few weeks earlier, though the situation with regard to the pandemic was different then. You have been informed that denial by the administration to allow the fair may anger certain sections of the community and give credibility to allegations of bias against the administration. You have also received confidential reports that such denial may be misused by local politicians to flare up communal tension and the situation may spiral out of control. In this context: (a) What are the various issues involved in this situation? (b) Identify the various options that you have and highlight your course of action.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
(a) Issues involved in the situation -
- There's a conflict between two fundamental rights granted by Constitution under -
Article 21 - Right to life Article 25 - Right to freedom of Religion.
- There's also issue of maintenance of law and order. - Religious sentiments of individuals and community at large.
However, if we examine closely Article 25 says - Freedom of religion is subject to public health, law and morality.
(b) Options available -
1. Allow fair to happen. +ve -> communal forces will remain silent. politicians will also not raise heads. religious sentiments will also not be hurt. -ve -> Risk of life of people participating in fair as well as people who will come in contact of them later. high life risk of everyone.
2. Do not give permission for the fair. +ve - COVID cases won't increase because of gathering. People will be safe. -ve - may lead to communal violence and falling law & order.
Alternative Course of Action - I'll talk to the religion's heads and explain them the hazards involved in organising gatherings at this point in time to their own lives and everyone else. These religion heads can then convey the idea locally. Common people listen to their religion's heads. - I'll make sure Disaster Management Act 2005 is implemented properly and no gathering happens. - I'll talk to the police heads (SSP & SP) who will convey to local police to be ready for unforeseen situation. In case, anything happens. - I'll also talk to the political leaders to not instigate communal ideas. It could be injurious to everyone's health/life.