Topper Copies

Despite having a robust legal architecture in the form of Disaster Management Act, 2005, a coordinated on ground response to disaster remains in a state of want. Comment.

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

Disaster Management Act, 2005 is India's structural backbone to manage any kind of disaster - natural or manmade.

NDMA guidelines are issued under the Act.

Disaster Management Architecture

Lack of Coordinated Ground Response to Disaster

1. No District disaster relief force present 2. Top down orientation and lack of bottom up support 3. Citizen participation is unstructured and not legally guaranteed 4. Confusion among NDRF and deployment of district forces - violates Unity of Command. 5. Lack of volunteers like Aapda Mitra in all states 6. Response given is after funds are sanctioned from the top & not continuous.

Solutions

1. Mix of Bottom up and top down approaches 2. Better social audit mechanisms (CAG report highlights violations in Disaster relief) 3. Creation of permanent infrastructure at ground level. 4. Participation of CSOs should be institutionalised

5. Sendai Framework based implementation from the bottom up (Eg Building code for resilient critical infrastructure)

Disaster Relief requires calibrated, coordinated, holistic action with local support and intelligence, & centralised resources