Topper Copies

Moral quality of an action should be judged by its consequences on human happiness. Discuss.

Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025

The statement mentioned above explains the concept of utilitarianism.

Utilitarianism is an idea which is based on consequences rather that action. It says that all actions are moral that leads to the happiness/good of maximum people.

- Maximisation of happiness is the idea behind utilitarianism. - It doesn't define what actions are good or bad. It necessarily defines just that the consequences decide the moral quality of an action.

However, there are certain limitations to this ideas - 1. lot of ambiguity of what actions can be good and what can be bad. 2. We cannot decide prior if a particular action with lead to happiness or sadness. 3. Problem in situations like - eg: In an organ transplant hospital, with many patients. The organs of one individual can lead to happiness of 3-4 individuals. Is it right then? Obviously not, but utilitarianism leaves us in a puzzle.

Thus, human happiness should also be rationalised with the effect it have on other people. Moral quality should not solely be based on consequences. It should be guided by end-oriented actions.