Topper Copies

The tenets of independent judiciary, life-breath of constitutional democracy, stand perpetually undermined by the executive encroachment into the judicial domain. Discuss.

Banna Venkatesh, AIR 15, 2024

Independent judiciary is fundamental to protect and safeguard the rights of citizens and promote checks and balances in functioning

Independent judiciary - undermined by executive encroachment 1. Attempts to appoint judges by executive. eg: National judicial appointment commission (NJAC) 2. Role of executive in quasi-judicial bodies functioning eg: tribunals appointments, condition of service, salary etc.. 3. Delay in appointment by executive: eg: Various collegium recommendations are kept on hold by center 4. Sidelining judiciary: eg: appointment of CEC, judge is replaced by minister in committee 5. Lack of enough support from executive in strengthening judicial infrastructure. eg: poor quality of facilities, lack of video conferencing facilities in courtrooms etc..

Inspite of this, executive supported judiciary functioning through: - e-courts mission: Infrastructure development - Mediation council act 2022: strengthening alternate dispute resolution - Strengthening infrastructure through grants, funds.

Measures needed to successfully strengthen judiciary 1. Observance of separation of powers: Art 50 of DPSP. 2. Working with judiciary in tandem: eg: establishment of NGT after M.C. mehta case 3. Achieving consensus on appointments to judiciary: eg: Reformed NJAC with greater scope for judiciary 4. Preventing judicial members from post-retirement benefits in government by compromising on their duties. eg: judges getting cool off period before taking up any other practice

Judiciary, which is watchdog of the rights of people has crucial role to play and it needs to be strengthened accordingly to achieve the intended role as envisaged.