How will you explain that Indian federalism is a happy mix of Unitarianism and confederalism?
Banna Venkatesh, AIR 15, 2024
Indian federalism, is a mix of unitary and confederalism, designed to achieve the unique needs of the country at its formation
Indian federation - happy mix of unitary & confederalism 1. Emergency provisions: State from federal to unitary without any amendments to constitution 2. Residual powers with center: to promote uniformity across country. 3. Integrated judiciary, unitary feature for peace and justice 4. 7th schedule: rights of states as sovereign and supreme in their jurisdiction 5. Rajyasabha: promoting interests of states, at central level. 6. Inter-state water disputes: power to center to make laws: promoting balanced interests of all states.
Inspite of this, there are certain irritants in the federal setup:
1. Increasing unitary features: eg: one nation one election etc.. promoting centralisation 2. Center-state disputes: - GST reforms - financial devolutions & grants - Delimitation issues 3. Encroaching state powers: eg: Farm laws by center, though agriculture is state subject.
Institutional mechanisms like Inter-State council under Art 263 should be strengthened to promote dialogue & consensus to make Indian federalism work for all.