Copying is safe; innovation demands courage.
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
In 1967 when America was involved in Veitnam war with USSR; no one anticipated that the great boxer of America Mohommad Ali will be standing at the crossroad. On one hand, he might have safely copied others in supporting the American war.
But he chose the other way - unprecendented, novel that made all the difference in his life. He courageously refused to involve in Veitnam crisis; which took away all his boxing titles and rewards.
Copying might have been safe for Ali to preserve his valuables. But he innovated and demonstrated how values are more important than valuables.
It is easy to be a sheep who has to follow the others without thinking much. But is it really safe, if the whole flock is jumping off a cliff? It is difficult to stand alone with unique and unpopular ideas. But is it only the courage that determines the good essence of innovation?
Let us delve into these questions in the essay.
Copying refers to imitation of established ideas or traditions. In context of Indian political system as a post-colonial state, we followed the Parliamentary form of government because we were familiar with it during British rule.
Innovation, in contrast, refers to critical examination of existing ideas and creating new ways of life. Again in Indian polity, there is novel positive secularism, which unlike western traditions promote the ethos of Sarva Dharma Sambhava.
It is safe to copy because you have the footsteps to direct your way ahead. The task of discovering path has already done, you just have to copy it. For instance, ISRO placed Aditya L1 solar mission on Lagronge point 1. This point was already researched for its equilibrium propesties.
But to innovate, it requires courage. In Aditya L1 mission, ISRO demonstrated courage by studying the unknown propesties of coronol mass ejections. It requires courage to withstand solar waves while studying them.
Now, the question comes to our mind, what is the purpose of copying and innovation? Recognizing the essence of imitation and innovation is crucial for co-creation and re-creation.
The safe zone of Copying promotes social cohesion and stability. Don't you agree that continued traditions of love, care, loyalty, honesty are binding glues of humanity as well as cosmos?
In the rythm of Interdependence when we copy our ancestors as well as co-species, we discover and re-discover the ways of life. To be specific, the traditions of Tribal Arts such as Wardli painting, Basohli Art have given identity, pride and livelihood to millions in generations.
However, in the safety of continued traditions, we start conforming to unquestioned norms. As Socrates rightly said,
"An unexamined life is not worth living"
We may be safe in our comfort zones of imitation but these can turn inhumane stagnated principles such as Caste System, Rigid Patriarchy and Racism.
That's why innovation comes in when courageous people like Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, Savitribai Phule and Nelson Mandela ask the intolerable questions.
In the history of mankind, society has been unkind to novel ideas. Socrates was poisoned and Galileo was killed when they innovated in politics and science, respectively. It needs courage to say that earth revolves around sun in a society where there is religious hegemonic discourse conforming the other way.
In addition, innovation tests the resolute will of the individual when they have never encountered the path ahead. To illustrate, let us time travel to Chitradurga fort in the 18th century.
An ordinary housewife saw something strange happening. She witnessed enemy soldiers of Haider Ali forces entering the fort through secret narrow opening. She was never trained to fight. But she armoured herself with pestle and strong will power, one by one killed all.
She is none other by Onake Obave, the brave lady of Karnatka. She demonstrated courage in unprecendeted way.
Indeed Innovation requires strong will power but copying is also not always safe endeavour. Sometimes, it is unethical like Plagiarism. The Black Box syndrome of AI is one such concerning issue.
Looking from different angle, Copying and sustaining the long held traditions require Collective will power. For instance, Trumponomics bullying innovations are easy with tariff, border, new discources on tariff, border and globalization.
But to sustain American soft power, it required strong Committment to global order through Us AID and liberal instihitionalism.
Indeed, it requires courage to innovate ideas such as mass destruction through nuclear weapons. But not all innovations, howsoever courageous are righteous. It requires ethical examination that leda to empowering innovations like Atoms for Peace.
Similarly, it is safe to copy great powers in anarchical & hierchical world order. For example; African scramble, earlier done by British and French powers and now by Us and China. But such imitations lack the essence of Collective good.
It requires the spirit of democracy to imitate the ethnic cohesion of Scandinavian countries and ethnic accomodation of Indian Constitution. Such best practice to be imitated in Middle-east for long lasting peace and development.
In matters of social stability and positive peace, imitation is the key. It provides sense of togetherness and safety. But in matters of examination and reforms, innovation is the key. With courage to confront evil traditions, good people must raise their voice.
As Plato enlightened us that there is evil in the society, not because of bad people but silence of good people.
Let us take pledge not to be silent and imitator of evils even if we are safe. As Mohammad Ali took innovative and courageous stand, let us be a chorus of truth and Justice.
Let us innovate with courage unless we discover the truth. And when we discover it, let us echo it again and again, for true peace and justice.
As Martin Luther King said:
Peace is not the absence of Violence, it is the presence of Justice