A bridge is being built by a powerful local contractor in a district. The Public Works Department (PWD) is responsible for issuing the tender, checking the quality of the bridge and giving approval to it. During the construction of the bridge, testing by the quality control lab in the PWD showed its strength to be slightly below the minimum value required for granting approval for its further construction and completion. The local contractor paid hefty bribes to some officials in the PWD to get the contract. These officials are pressurising the quality control lab in the PWD to sign the report and give the required approval to the bridge. The local MLA is also pressuring the concerned lab for the approval, as elections in the state are approaching and the bridge has to be inaugurated. However, the in-charge of the lab is aware that if he grants approval and any mishappening related to the bridge occurs in the future, he may come under scrutiny. In this context, answer the following questions: (a) What are the issues involved in this scenario? (b) Evaluate the options available to the in-charge of the quality control lab in the given situation. (c) What course of action should the lab in-charge take? Justify with logical arguments.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Infrastructure development is one of the key responsibilities of the government, with that it should also ensure public safety.
(a) The key Issues involved in the Scenario
- Public Safety - weak bridge may fall and endanger peoples lives. eg :- In case of Morbi Bridge, Gujarat. - Influence of local contractor among officials. - Compromise on the integrity of quality check by lab incharge. - Corrupt officials in Department. - Influence of MLA, using his power to mobilise public against lab incharge or influence transfer. - Governments responsibility to be accountable for tax payers money utilisation in efficient manner.
(b) Options Available to in-charge
1. Give approval +ve - a) local contractor will be happy b) Officials and MLA will also be in support. -ve - a) Public safety is endangered. b) If any mishap happen, he'll be charged for homicide and held liable in investigation c) Compromise on ethical code of conduct vowed before coming to services. 2. Do not give approval +ve - a) Human life won't be endangered. b) In-charge not be liable in future for any mishaps. -ve - a) In-charge might be transferred. b) Officials will turn against you. Office will have -ve environment.
(c) Course of action to be taken by lab-incharge
a) Prepare a report about the issues in quality substantiated by facts and evidences. b) Present the report to his higher officials and gain their opinion about his findings. If supported, should not grant approval to the project. c) Should also talk to MLA about how he has to stay in area for long and if anything wrong happens with the bridge, people will completely turn against him. Instead, issue fresh tender and give quality service to people. d) Initiate corruption charges against the officials and the contractor. CBI inquiry must be held to look into the matter.
Its important to maintain Integrity and act right even under pressure. Public service, and ensuring its safety should be the foremost priority. Government is liable to protect its people.