You are a young officer posted as a Sub-Divisional Magistrate in a backward district. You receive a complaint against the appointment of a Dalit woman in a village school for cooking food under the Mid-Day Meal scheme by parents of some students. The parents are putting immense pressure on the school management to discontinue the services of the woman concerned on the basis of long-standing social norms of caste impurity. They also say that if the management fails to take a favourable decision, keeping in mind the prevailing social customs, they will convene a village assembly and take action against the woman and her family members, including boycotting them socially. Based on the above information, address the following: (a) Identify the issues involved in the given case study. (b) Highlighting the reasons behind continuing caste discrimination, discuss the steps which you will take to resolve the present issue.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Gandhiji termed Caste as a social evil. Ambedkar also held that caste discrimination as a termite, eating the Society slowly. However, it has been rooted in our society since generations.
(a) Issues Involved in the Case study
- Despite 75 yrs of Independence & existence of constitution that prohibits discrimination- Article 16,15 and Prohibits untouchability - Article 17. Still caste based discrimination exists. - Village assemblies (Panchayats) given constitutional status and expected to implement Indian constitution, still grounded in orthodox thinking - Parents compromising on education of children, they also learning discrimination from parents and pass on to their children - Endangers employment of Dalit women. - Degenerates her dignity. - Faces social atrocities. Fear of her family being boycotted because of her.
(b) Reason for continuing Caste based Discrimination
- Caste Discrimination has existed for a very long time. Its rooted in almost all aspects of life - food, marriage, cloths, economy etc. It'll take a time for generations to be aware. - People belonging to SCs and STs are generally not aware of their rights. They don't know Prevention of Atrocities Against SC/STs Act exists. So Redressals have been low. - National commissions for SCs and STs have been working for their upliftment. But the scale required has not been achieved. Their reports are mere recommendations. - Higher castes enjoy their domination and power in the region. Doesn't let SCs and STs uplift themselves. - According to NCRB report, only 34% conviction rate in SC/ST discrimination charges. The powerful get away.
Actions I'll take to resolve the issue:
- I'll go to the school and eat food made by Dalit women along with children and my team. - I'll raise awareness campaigns in school and ask teachers to educate children. Give examples like Prez Draupadi Murmu and former President Ram Nath Kovind. - I'll talk to the parents and make them aware of legal aspects. Charges under Article 15,16,17. and also Prevention of Atrocities against SCs and STs. - I'll also talk to members of village assembly - the Sarpanch - and tell them about their adherence to the Indian Constitution.
Caste Discrimination is still an imp issue in our country. It needs to be addressed by raising awareness and education & efforts to make them economically strong.