Topper Copies

(a) It is argued that the Indian bureaucracy suffers from indecision and risk aversion. Do you agree? Justify with logical arguments.

Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025

Indian Bureaucracy is stronghold of Indian Democracy. Yet, it faces some Issues. It generally suffers from indecision & risk aversion mainly because -

1. Its recommendations to ministers are advisory in nature. 2. They are not directly liable for any public policy effects. 3. They have job security unlike private sector, where their job is secured by their work contribution. 4. They are subjected to frequent transfers, so lack of enthusiasm to take strong action against certain issues. 5. They are often under pressure from political figures. So, they do not oppose them, as political leaders have stronghold among people of the region.

However, its not always the case. If an officer has will to bring a change they take strong actions and bears all the risks. eg: Jayaprakash Narayan - massive rehabilitation bid for 8000 youth belonging to displaced families of Vishakhapatnam Steel Plant. - JM Lyngdoh, posted in Bihar, refused to be guided by huge political pressure.

Thus, if a man has will, there's always a way. Civil Servants need to always remember his ethics & work for the people.