You are CEO of a company, which is involved in manufacturing of large-scale copper products. It has created good employment opportunity for the locals. But the local residents are not happy with the management of the company and big group of local residents are protesting continuously. They are demanding closer of the plant as factory discharge is contaminating the local water sources. Your father is a senior IAS officer placed in the concerned Ministry. He is influential and very well networked. Company's management is pushing you to manage the situation and local authority through your father, as putting high quality production facility in plant will increase the cost of production, and company may loose market share in terms of sales if cost goes high. Based on the above situation answer the following questions: (a) What are the options available to you? (b) Discuss merits & demerits of each option. (c) What will be your final call? Justify.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
The situation depicts a conflict between personal gains and moral values. The following options are available-
(1) Giving in to the demands of the company. This isn't the right thing to do, as this would create wrong precedent and dereliction of duty by my father.
(2) Dodging the calls of the company staff to give them a hint that economy won't outnumber environment.
(2) Informing my father about the company influencing me so that he may take strict action against them.
My final call would be to take a combination of (2) + (3) & to set the right precedent and also to be able to protect local water sources to be contaminated.
(3) If possible the govt. can assist the company in employing hi tech to make it a zero discharge based water source to ensure that the govt comes on board with the company.
(4) Also locals can be taken into confidence about the efficacy of the plant and the employment it would generate.
(5) Crowdfunding can also be done. Else Green bonds may be launched.