You are head of a charitable trust that takes care of education, clothing, food & other basic needs of children from marginal community. Your organization also offers health services to the members of weaker section. You find it difficult to serve qualitatively because of the crunch of funds. Trust runs on donations and contributions from donors only. There is a regular fall in contribution from several imminent persons who were prime donors previously. Now you have decided to go for small advertisement to get donation for the good cause. Response is not very encouraging, however, a prominent local politician with a criminal record offers a hefty donation. The options available are: (a) Take donation from that politician. (b) Reject offer of that politician as his track record is poor. (c) Ask him to directly assist to those who are in need. (d) Reduce your operational scale to affordable level, so that you can sustain charitable work. Analyse each option with its consequences.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
The dilemma here is to whether look at this problem from a deontological perspective or from a teleological perspective. If means are taken as ends, taking money from a criminal would be a vice. If ends are considered, helping the poor is a virtue. Lets analyse the available options -
(a) Taking donation from the politician may make monetary crisis disappear but this would bring wrong precedent for the society. Also, s/he may be donating for electoral reasons.
(b) Although this may direct his wrath on me, but morality doesn't allow me to take donation from someone who isn't worthy enough.
(c) While asking him to directly assist may still be used by him for electoral gains, but may be s/he is experiencing a change of heart and wants to give back to the society. One may recommend it to him to contribute directly, but the final decision will be his/her.
(d) Until funds aren't available, this would be the best option to follow or else the elders of this marginal community can be roped in to make traditional items and sell them for a considerable price.
NGO's and govt can also be roped in by tweeting to the Home Minister directly.