Topper Copies

You are a doctor in a government hospital. One of your lady friends got married in very rich and influential family. However, with passage of time you came to know that the family is very conservative as she visited you to seek your help in determining sex of the child at fetus stage. As her in-laws want a boy child to act as inheritor of the family. They have also ordered to abort the child if it is girl. Later her in-laws insisted hard and connected the doctor with the health minister on mobile phone. The minister said the doctor to help them in all possible manners without saying anything about the issue at hand. Thus reporting about the issue to police is waste. Answer the following questions: (a) What are the ethical dilemmas in the above case? (b) Do you think that your moral obligation also demands to help your friend? (c) A doctor in a public or government hospital should obey the health minister for whatever he says. Do you agree and why? (d) What steps will you take in the above situation?

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The case aptly shows the pathos developed in our patriarchal society and despite pre-conception sex determination being barred in our country, such cases have appeared.

(a) The ethical dilemmas involved in this case are whether to give in due to external pressure (health minister) or do what is legally and ethically right. One may be wary of being in the bad books of Health minister, by not following him/her, but the guilt of accepting his demands may cause problems as well.

(b) It is my moral, legal and ethical obligation to help my friend in a way that illegal sex determination isn't done, simultaneously the personal relations of the friend are not spoiled with her husband and in-laws. Morality, above all, shall dictate that a right precedent needs to be set and people need to be made aware that boys and girls are equal.

(c) A doctor needs not necessarily work as per the health ministers diktats. S/he needs to act in an ethical ways and medical ethics disallow doctors to give-in to the whims and fancies of the health minister. As a doctor, one needs to do what is good for the patient and also legal. The health Minister doesn't own the doctors of the country as such.

(d) Delicate handling of the situation needs to be done! Several measures will have to be taken simultaneously- - Refuse the health Minister for such sinister actions citing legal & ethical constraints. - Contact the Medical council of the case to ensure they simply do the procedures with another doctor. - Call on to the conscience of the lady's family about the futility of such immoral acts and ideas.

Take the lady in confidence, that she needs to raise her voice and tell the family, that had her mother killed her how would they have a vanshaj.

- The lady's parents can be called to provide her the moral support. - The lady's husband can be easily persuaded for he doesnt belong to the old generation & is more open to new ideas.