Topper Copies

You are a senior civil servant. One of your officer friend is hard working, completes her work on time but always demoralizes her subordinates by blaming them for one or the other thing. She keeps everyone on toes. Often she shouts in her office and want to just follow the blue book while working. She also insults junior officers if one fails to get the things done. Her only mantra to work is to "get the things done-whatever it takes." Due to this bossy attitude your friend is not liked by the subordinates and because of her uneven relation with her team members, she fails to portray a good office culture. Most of the colleagues know about this case but no one wants to discuss it because of your proximity with that lady officer. However, one day, one close friend happens to be your colleague briefed about the problem subordinate officers are facing. Answer the following questions based on the above case. Bring merits and demerits related to each course of action and discuss the best option. (a) Directly talk to subordinate and assure about correcting the things in future. (b) Give responsibility to your friend who briefed you about this case. (c) Transfer the lady officer as this case may bring sorry figure for you also in future. (d) Request the lady officer not to do so as this may hamper their personal relations also. (e) Is there any better option available to correct the things other than that mentioned above?

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The problem faced in such a situation is that of a conflict between one's official duties and personal rapport, while ignoring any of these may create dissonance within the self. Let's analyze all the given options -

(a) Directly talk to subordinate and assure about correcting the things in future. Direct talks with the subordinates may foster confidence among them and give them a faith that all will be well in future. Demerits- This will disrupt the hierarchy of bureaucratic control and may not be the most appropriate action to take.

(b) Give responsibility to your friend who briefed you about this case. Merits- This may lift the burden on me, but thats not the aim I am striving for. Demerits- This will hamper my relations with the lady officer and also no change may be done because of this.

(c) Transfer the lady officer as this case may bring sorry figure for you also in future. Merits- This is like passing the buck & she may still not mend her ways, as no dialogue has taken place, only a knee jerk reaction of punishing her has been done. Her right to be heard is violated.

(d) Request the lady officer not to do so as this may hamper their personal relations also- Merits- This will ensure dialogue, through which she would be made aware of the rising resentment against her, despite her being finishing all work on time. Demerits- The talks will have to be comprised of both formal & informal talks in a way that she is motivated to mend her ways.

(e) other option available- Public relations should rise above private relations and one needs to ensure that she mends her ways, While talks may suffice for a start, about how she needs to bring in a change in her attitude, else, appropriate official action can be taken against her for spoiling the work culture and disturbing mental peace of other subordinates.