What is doctrine of double effect? Does 'Principle of Permissible Harm' stand the test of moral laws?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Doctrine of Double Effect implies that an action may have an intended positive effect and simultaneously an unintended harm which may or may not be foresighted. For Ex- While treating complexities developed in a Pregnant woman, a doctor may save the woman, but might not save the child. But, she didn't wish to do that, but it did have a double effect.
"Principle of Permissible Harm" states that while an action may do a considerable amount of good, it might cause some harm which wasnt intended but could be foresighted. Ex- In case of Euthanasia, while trying to ease out the pain of the patient, the doctor may be actually killing the patient.
In Real life, usually such dilemmas occur, where one has to weigh the benefits and problems arising out of a complex situations and it is here where "Principle of Permissible Harm" holds significance.
Thus, moral laws allow "Principle of Permissible harm" as all situations in real life are not a Yes/No type situation and one has to outweigh positives with negatives to arrive at a situation.