The Ninth Schedule fabricated a constitutional paradox to safeguard laws related to socio-economic justice from being challenged under the fundamental right to property. Does the ninth schedule have any relevance in present times? How did the IR Coelho judgment resolve this paradox?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Ninth schedule was brought via First Constitutional Amendment to undertake land reforms effectively.
Ninth schedule - constitutional paradox
It makes laws immune from Judicial Review and was aimed to forego fundamental rights of some, to uphold distributive Justice.
With time many states and centre started brushing up controversial laws under the carpet leading to widespread demand of misuse of this legislative innovation.
Ex- TN providing 69% reservation (above the 50% set under Maneka gandhi case)
Relevance of 9th Schedule presently
1. To ensure distributive justice 2. Utilitarian principle. Ex- Large Dams which will provide electricity to many, will require displacement of some. 3. Gives extra space for legislative and executive to work 4. Reduces litigation by people accusing state of taking sides.
Not Relevant
1. Justice should not only be done, but seen to be done 2. May lead to autocratic tendencies 3. Central and state governments can misuse these provisions 4. Human Right violations can occur due to such unbridled power.
IR Coelho case
All laws added after 24 April 1976 (Keshavanand Bharti case) will be subject to Judicial Review based on "basic structure doctrine".
Paradox Resolved - Yes
As a blanket immunity has no place in a legislature, but
1. Basic structure remains undefined 2. Collusion of Judiciary and executive can ignore Human Right violation. 3. Subject to whims and fancies of L-E-J trinity.
Thus, a solution would be to codify basic structure like Germany did, to prevent its misuse.