Topper Copies

Under what circumstances can the Governor reserve a state bill for the consideration of the President and why is the provision controversial? Also, discuss the reforms suggested by Punchhi Commission in this regard.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Ar 199 and Ar 200 mentions the proviso where governor can reserve a state bill for Presidents consideration and has been highly debated.

Cases of reservation of central assent for state bill

1. Restricts freedom of trade between states 2. In any way curtail powers of HC 3. When governor deems it fit

This provision is controversial because

1. Gubernatorial Procrastination: Governor uses sheer discretion to send the bill to President. Ex- NEET Bill and Kerala's Lokayukta Bill. 2. Source of tussle between elected government and Governor, as it often leads to inordinate delay. 3. Stalls democratic process. 4. Lack of suspensive veto - President can't give assent to it even after it reaches to him twice. 5. Affects separation of Power - Executive stalls legislative process. 6. Issues with governors discretion - S/he is often seen as centre's agent and leads to mistrust. 7. Leads to state becoming puppets in the hands of the centre. 8. Specially misused when there are different parties at Centre and in state.

Punchi Committee recommendations

1. Governor to give reason for sending a Bill to President 2. It should be constitutionally specified as to which bills s/he can delegate (no discretion) 3. A time limit for President to come to conclusion - accept or reject it 4. Permanent Inter State Council under Ar 263 to resolve such challenges 5. Governor's term should be fixed and s/he should be a neutral person.

Thus, above recommendations of Punchi committee would ensure that Constitutional morality and Cooperative federalism - twin pillars of democracy are upheld.