The National Commission for Scheduled Tribe (NCST) has largely been confined to a monitoring and advisory role. What are the impediments in the functioning of NCST despite the constitutional status, also suggests reforms.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Ar 299B mandates constitution of NCST to look into the demands of ST and ensure their independence.
Mandate of NCST
- to look into cases of human rights violation - act as a civil court while summoning evidence - prepare and analyse reports on status of ST's. - ensure traditional farming like Jhum etc to flourish - ensure justice delivery to ST's
Issues with NCST
Advisory role
1. can't punish perpetrators 2. can't announce an award for compensation, only recommend it 3. heavily dependent on Ministry of Tribal Affairs for funds and functionaries 4. Advise future course of action, can't implement them 5. No power to demand Action Taken Report (ATR)
Monitoring Role
6. Can't take direct action, only monitor status of ST's 7. No role in punishment, only monitor the situation
Impediments in working of NCST
1. lack of funds, function and functionary. 2. Its role was never envisaged as an action taking body. 3. Doesn't have the means to carry out an investigation. 4. Duty of SC, HC and Subordinate courts to give justice. 5. Executive body mostly. 6. Judiciary unwilling to give it teeth.
Suggested Reforms
1. Envisage active role of the body by giving it powers 2. Suo-motu cognizance should be allowed to it 3. Training of NCST individuals to deal with judicial questions 4. Recommendations of Bhuria Committee to be used in letter and spirit. 5. Governor's Report - Allow them to take action.
Thus, to ensure substantive justice it is imperative that we give NCST the requisite teeth.