"Constitution envisages an independent judiciary, not insulated judiciary"; In the light of the given statement, discuss the issues associated with the appointment of judges in the higher judiciary and explore alternatives to the current system.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
While an independent judiciary leads to effective federalism, questions of our judiciary being isolated has been seen as a challenge for a long time.
Independent judiciary
- checks and balances ensured - separation of Power - Corrects Exe. and leg. Excesses
Issues in appointment of higher judiciary
1. Collegium system remains opaque. SC itself in Swapnil Kumar case said that sunlight is the best disinfectant. 2. Uncle Judge Syndrome - All judges come from a handful of families (highlighted in 2nd ARC). 3. Lack of Diversity - Only 12.5% HC and 13% SC judges are women, leading to serious blot on judiciary. 4. Cases of Mistrust - When Justice H.R. Khanna wasn't made CJI due to his ADM Jabalpur Case, it casted serious doubts on integrity of other judges. 5. Minutes of Meetings of collegium are not made public. 6. Insensitive judgements like tying Rakhi on Sexual harasser cast serious doubts on selection process. 7. Deviants like Justice Karnan, raises demand for requirement of rechecking selection process.
Alternatives to current system
1. Release Minutes of the meeting of collegium. 2. Apply RTI rules on judges. 3. Make judges accountable for 5 crore pendency in cases. 4. Lokpal should have power over judges. 5. NJAC can be remodelled and brought up again. 6. Memoranda of Procedure to be made enforceable. 7. Live streaming of judgements. 8. Prevent use of archaic terms like "Your lordship", "My lord": It is a democracy, no one should use such terms. 9. Contempt of court should be codified.
Thus, Judiciary is the Lighthouse of Indian democracy and its effective functioning is of utmost importance.