Topper Copies

How has the 69th Constitutional amendment led to Delhi's dual governance dilemma? Discuss its impact on cooperative federalism as envisaged in the Constitution.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

69th Constitutional amendment changed Ar 239 AA to give special status to administration of Delhi owing its strategic locations.

69th CAA leading to Delhi's dual governance dilemma

Post of Lieutant Governor to help Delhi administration, to work based on aid and advice of Delhi's elected government.

3 state subjects viz Land, police and administrative services were brought under LG's purview.

There remained constant dilemma whether LG has to work on CoM's advice or if s/he can take equivocal decisions to use veto powers.

Impact on cooperative federalism

1. Overriding state list of Seventh schedule, leading to clashes. 2. Providing relative autonomy to Delhi's LG leading to "tussle for supremacy" between CM and LG. 3. Negates the mandate of a democratically elected government. 4. Leads to arm-twisting by Central government, especially when different parties rule at Centre and state. 5. Leads to delayed policy making. Ex- recent Delhi Govt's steps were backtracked by LG. 6. Centralising tendency - Recent ordinance to make National Central Civil Service Authority to decide "services distribution".

Reasons for Centralising tendencies

1. Indian cooperative federalism has Centralising bias (Ram Jawaya Case) 2. Necessary as it is state capital 3. Lack of Statehood, UT's come under Central government. 4. SC judgements have sometimes ruled in their favour. 5. Necessary for security of state and sovereignity and integrity of India.

Way forward

- make clear guidelines - use Punchi Commission recommendations to ensure better cooperation.

Thus, as pointed out by Moris Jones, India is a "bargaining federalism" and Delhi will have to constantly ask for its share.