"Equality under the Indian constitution is not merely about formal equality, it also incorporates the idea of substantive equality". Discuss this statement in light of constitutional provisions and relevant Supreme Court judgments.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Ar 14 of the Indian constitution provides for Equality Before law and Equal Protection of law, but that is only the tip of the iceberg.
Equality in Constitution = - Ar 14,15 Equality, no discrimination - Ar 29,30 Cultural equality - Ar 25-28 religious - Ar 332,334 upliftment SC,ST
Incorporating ideals of Substantive Equality
1. NM Thomas case - Court gave explicit directions of adhering to the principles of Substantive Equality. 2. Constitutional Morality - In Rameshwar Prasad case SC held that constitutionalism abhors absolutism and would work in favour of citizens. 3. Differential access - Through cases like Maneka Gandhi (50% ceiling), Lok Prahari case (upholding EWS reservation) SC ensured substantive justice. 4. Reducing "Locus standi principle" - PIL have now become a source of enforcing substantive Equality. Ex- Hussainara Khatoon case, 40,000 undertrials were set free in Bihar. 5. Ensuring distributive Justice. Ex- In Pradeep Jain Case, law on "son of the soil principles" were declared unconstitutional. 6. Right to Environment - part of equality (M.C. Mehta Case) - as it leads to differential liabilities on rich and poor. 7. Progressive ideals - decriminalizing section 377 (Navtej Jauhar case), Vishakha guidelines have ensured substantive justice.
Thus, Substantive Equality is the north star of Constitutional morality (Justice Chandrachud).