An influential politician, a third-time MP, was known in his State for his infrastructure development works, especially roads and irrigation canals. Acknowledging his developmental work and goodwill, the Party appointed him the State Party President. Since his Party is also the ruling Party in the State, the MP has started working closely with the Chief Minister. After six months of becoming the Party President, the MP learned that a sizable amount of development funds were diverted to party promotional activities. Further, a few mega-development projects were allocated to the relatives of the CM and a few of his close ministers. The MP was neither impressed nor happy with how the State government managed the development funds because the Party had won the last elections promising development and clean administration. There was a lot of financial corruption in the State ministries; some of the ministers used the State machinery for personal purposes. He knew if the Party continued to function the way it is now, it would be an electoral disaster in the next elections. The MP was a politician with a conscience. His dilemma was that, as a Party President, he had to ensure his Party won the next elections. To do that, he had to clean up the State administration, which meant locking horns with the CM, an extremely powerful figure well-supported by the Partys senior members. And importantly, the MP was unwilling to risk his political career, which he had built after years of hard work. 1. What do you think are the issues involved in the above case? 2. What options are available to the MP in the above case? 3. Evaluate the options and suggest a course of action to the MP. 4. Distinguish between political and bureaucratic corruption. Can bureaucracy play a role in checking political corruption?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
The cases of financial misappropriation by those in power is on the rise leading to such situation of crises of conscience.
(1) Issues involved
a) If the MP opens up the misappropriation case, party's image would get tarnished b) Any accusation against the CM, wont be taken well by his supporters c) he would need ample finances and proofs to prove that there were financial misappropriation d) What if his party members don't support him and are hand in glove with corruption e) what if party loses the next election, who will take responsibility
(2) Options available
a) Take strict action against CM b) Collect evidence and show it to party workers and garner support c) Refer the case to Lokpal/Lokayukts and start an enquiry d) Let the CM forego
(a) strict action
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | strong action will ensure in future people abstain from corruption | absence of support | | immediate resolution to the problem | his CM's supporters might launch a vicious campaign against MP |
(b) Evidence collection
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | will give evidence | suspicion of CM | | Strong case against the CM | wrath of party worker |
(c) Lokpal referral
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | No crises of conscience | against party workers | | Deliver on Party promises of clean development | relations with CM will be strained forever |
(d) No action
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | good relations | Crises of conscience | | No stress of proving him guilty | against public trust |
Course of action should be (c) followed by (d) to ensure effective justice delivery
(4)
| Political Corruption | Bureaucratic Corruption | |---|---| | at politician level | by bureaucrat | | Legislative level | Executive level |
both lead to loss of public trust
bureaucracy can check corruption by 1. Transparent fund disbursal 2. CAG audit at regular intervals 3. ensure all fund reaches beneficiary
As mentioned in Kautilya's Arthashastra, Kantak shodhang (corruption erosion) is most important