Discuss the mandate of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT). To what extent earlier SC verdicts have resolved the jurisdictional tussle between CAT and High courts?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Ar 323 A established Central Administrative Tribunal on Swaran Singh committee's recommendation to look into service matters.
Mandate of CAT
1. Service Matters of civil servants and All India Servants are looked after 2. Adherence to Service rules - Code of Conduct for AIS is followed. 3. Principle of Natural Justice is the key to ensure discussions related to promotion, transfers are discussed. 4. Evident Act is given less importance to while hearing cases of suspension etc.
Issues of tussle with High Courts
Initially, appellate jurisdiction from CAT was given to SC, thereby bypassing HC (Ar 226 was overlooked).
In L. Chandra Kumar case, the court decided that in lieu of Ar 226 and Ar 142 ("complete justice"), appeals from CAT would lie to HC.
Issues: - leads to long judicial years of unresolved case - tribunalisation of justice - enhanced pendency of cases.
Thus, SC has largely solved jurisdictional tussle between CAT and HC, but still matters of subjects of both remain unresolved and overlapping.