Fundamental Duties are a reminder that citizenship is not merely a passive status but an active engagement. Discuss. What are the challenges in their legal enforcement?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Fundamental Duties are the "Kartavya" that should be followed by citizens, mentioned in Ar 51-A, by 42nd Constitutional amendment on recommendation of Swaran Singh Committee.
Fundamental duties -> active citizens
1. Governance a two way street: In Javed vs State of Haryana case, SC held that fundamental rights should be seen on premise of fundamental duties.
2. Responsible citizens: to - protect Environment - Safe use of monuments - enforce brotherhood - respect women 3. Also enhance citizen's rights. Ex: Right to clean Environment (Mc Mehta case) requires other citizens to enforce it. 4. Promotes social decency and solidarity. Ex- Respect for women is bound to create mutual trust. 5. Social contract of citizen - to abide by rules of the state. 6. Source of law - Justice Verma committee highlighted laws made out of duties. Ex - Flag code etc.
Challenges in legal Enforcement
- difficult to ensure accountability - vaguely worded, creates litigation: "honour ideals of freedom struggle" is subject to interpretation - will increase case pendency (already 5 crore cases pending) - prone to misuse - burden on citizens
Thus, as stated by B.R. Ambedkar, DPSP's should be accompanied with duties, not just as pious declaration, but with deeper effects.