You are an IAS officer, currently serving as the Secretary of the Public Works Department in a hill state. Recently, a disturbing incident has come to light involving a senior Cabinet Minister and two engineers of the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI). During an inspection of a critical highway project, the Minister was allegedly seen on video physically assaulting and verbally abusing the engineers in full public view. The video, recorded by bystanders, went viral on social media and was widely covered by television channels, sparking both outrage and support from different sections of society. The Minister later defended his actions, alleging that the officials were corrupt, unresponsive to local grievances, and responsible for inordinate delays in the project. He insisted that his actions were driven by public frustration and the urgency of delivering infrastructure to a remote region. However, the engineers have filed a police complaint and written to their superiors, claiming they were targeted for resisting political pressure to award contracts to specific local contractors linked to the Minister. As the situation escalated, a union of NHAI engineers declared a strike, demanding action against the Minister and protection of officer dignity. This has brought several critical infrastructure projects to a standstill, including road connectivity to tribal areas, pre-monsoon repair works, and strategic border roads. You have been directed by the Chief Secretary to prepare a fact-finding report, while also ensuring smooth coordination between state and central agencies. Meanwhile, the Minister's office is informally pressuring you to downplay the incident. The media is sharply divided - some portraying the Minister as a crusader against corruption, others condemning the act as a serious breach of administrative ethics and rule of law. Civil servants across departments have expressed concern about personal safety, dignity, and increasing political interference, while citizens are now growing restless due to halted infrastructure works. (a) What are the key ethical issues involved in this situation? Identify the stakeholders and their conflicting interests. (b) As the Secretary of the PWD, what actions will you take in above situation? (c) How do such incidents affect the morale of civil servants and public trust in governance?
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
(a) The above case study involves a serious assault on dignity of officials but also opens issues of institutional efficacy and political interference.
Key ethical issues
1. Violence and indignity to words officers. 2. Non-use of proper channels by minister. 3. Concerns regarding speed of completion of projects. 4. Crony capitalism in award of contract 5. Political interference in internal functioning of department. 6. Public trust where "justice must not only be done, but also be seen to have been done".
Stakeholder assessment
1. NHAI officials -> disclosed dignity, respect, safety | alleged corruption, unresponsiveness (conflict) 2. Cabinet minister -> expediting work | award of contracts to favourites (conflict) 3. Citizens' interests -> Timely completion & good functioning 4. Secretary, PWD -> resolving the issue and fact-finding for accountability -> conflicting with wrongdoer.
(b) As Secretary, PWD it will be essential to uphold neutrality, objectivity and non-partisanship. Like Elliot Ness, I will thoroughly investigate the facts, at the same time, I will attempt to resolve operational deadlocks that might be impeding project delivery.
Fact Finding Role 1. Interview the concerned officials, minister as well as take public statements of witnesses. 2. Look into allegations of delay and corruption of officials: check project timeline, extent of delay and any unfair dealing. 3. Look into credentials of bidders in tendering process and relations with minister. 4. Look into any broad roadblocks at a systemic level.
Report Preparation 1. If cogent evidence of violence & humiliation -> highlight illegality and impropriety of such actions. 2. Reveal evidence of unfair dealings, as obtained and advocate strict action.
Coordination role -> assure safety of officials -> mechanisms for ensuring timelines. eg> DMRC countdowns -> Ensure access to resources, state-center collaborations
(c) Impacts
Morale of civil servants -> loss of agency -> undermines dignity which is at the "heart of all other rights" (Supreme Court)
TSR Subramanian case: political interference - (i) distorts incentives, (ii) undermines merit, (iii) demoralizes work culture.
Public Trust -> abuse of power by cabinet minister -> shows impunity -> Allegations of extraneous considerations -> less trust in institutions -> Generates apathy & feeling of helplessness -> Inconvenience due to delays -> utilitarian loss of happiness of the many.
Hence, proper course of action is to address systemic issues in institutions and not personal capacity.