Topper Copies

Rashmi works with an NGO that operates non-residential State wide skill development centres. The organisations work primarily involved upskilling rescued drug addicts who belong to vulnerable sections of society. The objective was to upskill and rehabilitate them by finding employment opportunities and finally reintegrating them within the community. Rashmis responsibilities included counselling the victims and preparing them mentally and emotionally for a new life. The job involved a lot of one-on-one interaction with the addicts, and sometimes she was privy to personal information that others didnt have. Last month the authorities brought a 23-year-old widow to the centre. As Rashmi interacted with her, she discovered that the widow was introduced to drugs by her husband, who was an addict and had a history of crime. He apparently was killed by drug dealers because of some monetary dispute. The widow confessed to Rashmi that after the death of her husband, she had started selling drugs to support herself and her 4-year-old. This was a detail the police were unaware of. Further, she revealed that she and her childs life were in danger from the drug dealers her husband owed money to. In the last month, Rashmi noticed she was diligent in learning and committed to making a fresh start. One day Rashmi saw that she had been absent for almost a week. After asking around, Rashmi discovered that she had been arrested for peddling drugs. Rashmi went to meet her, and the widow became emotional seeing Rashmi and narrated the sequence of events. The widow said she was forced to sell drugs by the dealers to whom her husband owed money, and when she tried telling this to the police authorities, they refused to believe her and treated her as an accused. She needed help. Rashmi, moved by her plight, went with some of the Senior NGO workers to meet the Senior Officer in Charge to plead the widows case. Rashmi tried to persuade them that the widow was a victim, not the accused. 1. What are the issues and ethical dilemmas involved in the above case? 2. How would you proceed with the case if you were the officer in charge? 3. Explore relevant options and advise what course of action Rashmi should take. 4. How would you see the widow as a victim of her husbands crime or an accused? Justify.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Drug trafficking is a slow poison, and police officials are bound to take strong action against drug peddlers, but the case here is different.

(1) Issues and ethical dilemmas

(a) Is it right to sell drugs to sustain one's living. (b) What course of action will be able to save the widow? (c) What about the child's future? (d) How will one gather the proof for all this story (e) Should justice be retributive or punishment oriented (f) plight of widow vs larger crime of selling the drug

(2) As an officer in charge, one will have to proceed on facts

(a) Use intelligence to know about the veracity of Rashmi's claim

(b) If widow is a victim, utilize discretionary powers and use file notings to prove her victimisation. Also, provide her safety from the drug peddlers, get her son enrolled in a school and applaud Rashmi for her efforts

(c) If she doesn't come out clean, used the strictest provisions against her, as she is spoiling the youth. Send her child to school to not waste his childhood

(d) Ask Rashmi to prove their NGO's stand - that they aren't a part of the larger group of drug peddlers

(3) Rashmi has the following options

1. Ask the officer for help and give some evidence for widow's innocence 2. If the officer doesn't help in any way approach his/her senior. 3. If this plan fails too, approach the media. 4. Use the good will and social capital of NGO to launch a jan andolan for the widow to give her justice. 5. Ensure that some political leaders are also roped in to make the widow's case stronger

Widow as a victim - drug started by husband - debt of drug peddlers forced her to sell drugs - has a small child to fend for

Widow as abuser - could have stood against the situation, ensure taking moral high ground - should understand the far-fetched negative consequences

Thus, in the spirit of Nishkaam Karma, Rashmi should ensure full help to the widow