The United States and India have their own distinctive jurisprudence on freedom of speech and expression despite the similarities in constitutional provisions. Analyse.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
US, world's oldest democracy and India, world's largest democracy have areas of convergence and divergence in implementing Freedom of speech and Expression.
Similarities in Constitutional provisions
1. Freedom of speech and Expression envisaged 2. Independent Judiciary to deliver those laws 3. Constitution as source of privileges 4. Rule of law upheld 5. process of law established 6. Ensure courts deliver complete justice.
Despite the similarities, there are points of Divergence.
| India | US | |---|---| | Conservative: Ex- burning of flag not allowed | Liberal: burning of flag allowed | | Sedition (Ar 124A) still there | Not here | | Contempt of court, if anything against judges | allowed to criticise judges on individual level | | Jury system absent | Jury decides cases | | Single law to deliver justice | Different state and Central law | | Advisory jurisdiction | Not here |
Thus, both nations have prints of convergence and divergence based on local needs and historical facts.