Topper Copies

The recent Supreme Court judgments on human rights issues mark a remarkable shift in using International law and treaties not just as a source of inspiration but as a source of law. Examine with reference to relevant case laws.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Supreme Court in a bid to deliver complete justice (Ar 142) has started using international law as basis of justice delivery.

International Law as treaty

Here, if India hadn't signed a treaty, SC would absolve executive of all responsibilities. Ex- If migration treaty not signed, no need to let them remain in one nation.

Recent shift to humanitarian cases

1. Economic right - In Vodafone case, court upheld that retrospectively taxes can't be applied. 2. Fugitive economic offenders - In case of Vijaya Mallya, SC took international law as benchmark to bring this fugitive back. 3. Use of global commons - dictated on international treaties like UNCLOS, MARCOS. 4. In case of migrants, principle of allowing them habitable place was vouched for by SC. 5. Not to take negative influence, like recent declaration of declaring abortion illegal.

Thus, SC has evoked a global world view to ensure that citizens get complete justice based on Constitutional Principles.