Topper Copies

You are the VP (Operations) of a company that manufactures and supplies space probes and satellite equipment to Government space agencies. The company has been in the business for over four decades and has built considerable expertise in producing and delivering high-quality products. The business was good. As VP of Operations, it was your responsibility to ensure the completion of projects and deliverables on time. A critical deliverable was running behind schedule due to the non-availability of a specific raw material. The material in question was an environmentally hazardous chemical that the Environmental Ministry banned. But considering the importance of the chemical compound for the space industry, the Environment Ministry was planning to allow controlled use in about three weeks. You and the company management didnt have three week waiting time. Further, there was severe pressure from the Department of Space to complete the deliverable on time as a lot was riding politically on the project. After internal discussions, you met the Space Department officials to explain the predicament and request a deadline extension. When the meeting happened, you were shocked by the attitude of the Department officials. They refused to accept any delay and suggested circumventing the environmental ministrys prohibition and procuring and using the chemical. They justified it by saying the ministry would allow controlled use in a few weeks. So, why wait? Besides, they noted that the environment ministry doesnt understand space priorities and their intricacies. They pointed out that everything is justified in the name of national interest. 1. What are the issues involved in the above case? 2. What are the options available to you? 3. Discuss the merits and demerits of each option and select your chosen course of action. 4. What do you understand by National Interest? Do you think it is ethically justified for a nation to prioritise security and economics over and above social justice and social development priorities?

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Circumventing legal channels has become a normal detour and to do such a thing has become systemic, with officials suggesting one another to do it.

(1) Issues involved

(a) Completion of project within the given timeline is a priority for space programs. (b) Use of hazardous chemical by illegal procuring - it might danger lives - what if a spill occurs? Who will take responsibility (c) Attitude of space department officials who are ready to circumvent rules to reach a hasty decision. (d) What happens to state program, if the project is not delivered on time?

(2) Options available

(a) Listen to space officials and abide by their demand. (b) Wait for three weeks, procure the material and then give a go-ahead (c) Write a separate plea to Environment Ministry to allow use of that material. (d) Involve PMO in getting the required help - use social capital.

(3)

(a)

| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Space program will be delivered on time | Illegal and unethical | | Will ensure your image of an efficient VP doesnt get tarnished | might lead to "quid pro quo" questions, as procurement is illegal now -> and law will treat you on this |

(b)

| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Ethical and legal | Delay the project | | Ensure things happen the right way | against the duty to uplift scientific temperament | | No doubt on one's integrity | |

(c)

| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Taking the legal route and ensuring justice to space program | might not get a response | | | delay the project |

(d)

| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | will get help | might get rejected | | Legal | some delay |

It would be advisable to take step (c) and if that doesn't take off well proceed to step (d). The government's focus on space programs will lead to them helping us quickly. Slight delay in delivery of project won't take away the company's social capital, as it has delivered materials for a long time now.

(4) National interest is the collective interest of the nation against any threat.

It should not be used as a farce to enforce any policy which executive deems fit. Having said that security and economy should be prioritised because they are the flagbearers of bringing social justice and development.

Thus, based on a case-to-case basis, one's superintendence over other should be kept in line with our DPSP.