Topper Copies

5. (b) What ethical dilemmas arise from the use of economic sanctions in international relations, and how can policymakers balance these concerns with the need to punish illegal behaviours and compel political change?

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

The G7 group of countries have levied various economic sanctions on Russia since the onset of war, but such actions raise some concerns as well.

Ethical Dilemmas 1. Respecting Sovereignty v/s Advancing global interest All countries are sovereigns, economic sanctions threaten to undermine this sovereignty. Therefore nation states must carefully assess the need to protect global interest. 2. Singular Interest v/s Collective Interest Sanctions hurt the economic interest of the country but can potentially ensure global peace & security. 3. Short term gain v/s long term gain Sanctions can disrupt supply chains, global trade but in the long term can restore order & peace.

Balancing these concerns 1. Sanctions should be levied only as the last resort when all forms of dialogue & diplomacy fail to bring in political change. 2. Sanctions should be reasonable in their strictness so as to not antagonise the country into taking impulsive actions. 3. Sanctions should be time bound and should be lifted as soon as normalcy is restored. 4. Sanctions should not be used as a tool to coerce other countries for the sake of power play. 5. In addition to sanctions, alternate mechanisms like peace-building, refugee rehabilitation etc should also be explored. eg Peace summit in Switzerland to handle Russia Ukraine conflict 6. Like minded countries should mobilise as a pressure group to use persuasion as a tool to bring in positive change eg ASEAN 5 point agenda → Myanmar.

Ensuring global peace is not only a necessity but also a moral imperative, we must remember the value of Vasudeva Kutumbakam