Topper Copies

A case study in which an officer uncovers financial irregularities in a rural development scheme, implicating well-connected senior officials and politicians, and must decide how to act.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

65% of the population lives in villages, rural development is crucial for their progress. but financial irregularities retard this progress

Ethical issues 1. Selfishness leading to misappropriation of public funds for personal gains 2. Violation of impartiality, neutrality and non partisanship due to politician-bureaucrat nexus 3. issue of corruption 4. use of coercion to intimidate officials 5. misuse of authority by seniors 6. poor integrity of administration 7. apathy for wellbeing of rural community

Available Options A. Keep Quiet, and maintain status quo - merits: ensure personal safety in line with ethical egoism, safeguard career prospects - demerits: I will be complicit in corruption, cause guilt, retard development

B. Expose the irregularities - merits: upholds transparency, deters future corruption, prevents crisis of conscience - demerits: endanger career growth, threat to personal safety, given that seniors are well connected, they escape due to political patronage.

C. Consult Joint Secretary. - merits: expert opinion, protects own interest - demerits: Is may too be compromised, may attract backlash, delay

Chosen Course of Action I would go with option C, first I would like to exhaust all possible formal recourse by consulting my immediate senior. If they refuse to cooperate, then I would write to the Cabinet Chief secretary communicating the seriousness of the situation.

In the long run to prevent corruption I would 1. focus on local capacity building to conduct effective social audits to identify leakages at the grass root itself. 2. leverage technology for tracking and transfer of funds after proper KYC.

India ranks 86th on the corruption perception index, there is an urgent need to address this issue. Code of ethics is the need of the hour for public servants.