Topper Copies

A case study in which an officer, ordered by a minister to outsource work performed by department staff, and facing a transfer for resisting, must decide how to respond to the conflicting demands of the minister and her own staff.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

This is a case highlighting the issue of conflict of source of authority that public officials face in their dealings

Administrative issues 1. low levels of professionalism and efficiency in staff 2. issue of compliance with senior's order 3. disregard for chain of command, hierarchy and the scalar chain of the department.

Ethical issues 1. lack of empathy for the concerns of the staff 2. ego issue; prioritising positional authority 3. neglecting genuine well intended advice 4. poor esprit de corps within the department and its employees.

Writing to the Minister Yes I believe it was morally right for me to write the minister as 1. I resorted to this option only after exhausting all other options and standards of procedure. 2. I also marked a copy to the chief secretary and the head of department 3. My intentions were guided by 1. empathy for staff. 2. ensuring their wellbeing 3. compassion for their troubles due to job insecurity 4. justice for the staff

Options Available A. Comply with transfer orders immediately - merits: outsourcing will lead to efficiency, better service delivery, ensure obedience to senior - demerits: job loss of staff, moral discomfort for self, cause guilt.

B. Defy the orders and continue resisting outsourcing - merits: ensure job security for employees, prevent crisis of conscience - demerits: amount to insubordination, lets bad precedent, department's image suffers, efficiency suffers.

C. Blow the whistle, report to media - merits: increase awareness about issue, increase support for cause - demerits: violates idea of impersonality, may attract disciplinary actions, further agitate the senior

In this situation, I would try to contact the Chief secretary & Minister to put a stay on my transfer.

I would also urge them to explore alternatives to outsourcing like PPPs (Passport Seva Kendra by TCS + govt) and Capacity building to increase departmental efficiency. I would advice them to consider the merits of such solutions through a committee

After a proper evaluation if its found that Outsourcing is the best possible solution for quality service delivery, I would humbly take charge of my new posting.

Both adherence to morals and rules should guide officials to ensure Ethical administration.