Topper Copies

4. (b) "The motive has nothing to do with the morality of the action." In light of the above statement, do you think motive is irrelevant in determining the morality of an action? Explain your position with relevant examples.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

Several scholars of the consequentialist thought argue that it is the ends that matter and the means adopted or the intrinsic motivation guiding actions are irrelevant.

Arguments in favour Selfish and unethical motives may drive individual actions. Such actions are immoral as ends & means cannot be separated (Gandhiji). eg use of violent means for protesting against colonialism by revolutionaries was deemed immoral by Gandhiji

Arguments against Studying the motive can shed light on the intent of taking actions which can help in ascertaining immorality eg during Pokhran tests India tested nuclear weapons not to wage war but to protect its sovereignty, such action was considered moral by global community.

Therefore motives are a key determinant in evaluating morality of actions, interestingly both ethical and unethical motives can lead to moral actions.