Topper Copies

A case study in which a head of procurement, Mr Sharma, awards a contract to the most competent bidder, Mr Sharma's personal acquaintance, without disclosing the personal connection, prompting another bidder, Mr Patel, to question his impartiality.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

Public officials often have to balance proffessional commitments & duty and personal relationships

Conflict of interest is a situation wherein our experiences, values, social connections, ideology etc may hamper our ability to make objective and rational decisions.

This case study is a classic case of conflict of interest because

1. The Head of procurement has - 1. had a clean record 2. based his decision to award contract on the basis of competancy not favouritism 3. he tried to uphold professionalism

But on the other hand he erred because not only important for justice to be done its even more important for Justice to be seen to have been done.

By failing to disclose his personal association with Mr Sharma he created a reason for people like Mr Patel to question his credibility and competence.

Relevance of Impartiality & Non partisanship Impartiality is the ability to act without bias. Non partisanship ensures we act fairly without favouritism or nepotion. Both these have the following relevance in public service

1. it ensures efficiency and professionalism 2. it deters self serving behaviour and motivates public officials to work for public interest 3. it helps inculcates a sense of service and devotion to duty 4. facilitates rational decision making 5. helps public officials maintain their integrity and display probity 6. it deters against indulging in discrimination against any group of population 7. it deters misappropriation of public funds and ensures optimum utilisation of public resources.

Deciding the Situation 1. I would have recused myself from the position citing my personal connections with Mr. Sharma. 2. Given that his bid was the most competant, any rational officer would have seen his merit and awarded him the contract nevertheless. 3. It would have prevented - project delays - damage to my reputation - potential loss to Mr Sharma due to delay - not shared my relationship with Mr Sharma.

Professionalism along with integrity and impartiality are sine quo non for good governance.