Topper Copies

Give a comparative analysis of the tribal and mainstream societies. Is tribal society more progressive than mainstream society? Argue with examples.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

7.6% of the Indian population comprises of tribals whose culture differs from the mainstream culture significantly.

Comparative Analysis Regarding Women Mainstream culture is rooted in patriarchy, which subordinates women, eg dowry, son bias. On the other hand, tribal societies are often matriarchal, placing women with a high social regard, eg the Khasi tribe, where the youngest daughter inherits property.

Caste & Segregation Mainstream: society is divided on caste lines (Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya, Shudra) and discriminates against lower castes, eg untouchability against dalits. Tribals: no such segregation, everybody treated as equal.

[a sketch map of India marking tribes: Bishnoi, Bhil, Gujjar Bakerwal, Khasi, Jaintia, Gond, Irula, labelled TRIBES]

Religion Mainstream: focus more on religiosity and ritualism, eg elaborate hawans, pooja. Tribals: focus on deeper connection with the almighty and natural spirits.

Environment Mainstream: disregards forests, rivers etc, eg pollution of holy rivers, deforestation. Tribals: worship natural spirits, eg sacred groves are protected, the Bishnoi community → black buck conservation.

Cultural Erosion Mainstream: increased influence of westernization & globalization, eg celebration of Halloween, individualism rising. Tribals: still preserve their cultural richness, eg Bhoota Kola dance in Dakshin Karnataka.

Family Mainstream: increasing nuclearisation. Tribals: live in big joint families, strong bonds, less intergenerational bonds.

But tribals also face issues of witchcraft, human sacrifices, pseudoscience and backwardness, and low literacy, eg 45% of tribals are below the poverty line.

Nevertheless, mainstream culture can learn many progressive virtues by studying tribal cultural ethos.